Skip to main content
Microsoft Idea

Power BI

Needs Votes

Better Handle Column Types on Load in Dimension Tables

Vote (232) Share
Matt Allington's profile image

Matt Allington on 22 Mar 2019 21:05:17

When you load a dimension table (say a calendar table) in Power BI desktop, there are often lots of numeric columns that are not additive. Examples include Year, Month Number, Day of Week etc. By default (unless you set the data type to text) these numeric columns will have the default aggregation behaviour set to SUM. But they are not additive (of course). It would be much better to set these (dimension numeric columns) as "do not summarize". This could be managed in various ways that would be better than the current state. eg, you could simply mark all numeric columns in a calendar table as "do not summarize" by default and allow the user to change truly additive days (like isWorkingDay) to SUM when required. Even better, use the AI capabilites of Azure to work it out.

This idea was mentioned by Jeffery Wang in a meeting at the end of the MVP Summit 2019. No doubt Jeffery has his own ideas of how to execute this. It is a great idea and would add a lot of value to the majority of users.

Comments (6)
Matt Allington's profile image Profile Picture

Andreu fil on 19 Apr 2024 10:44:44

RE: Better Handle Column Types on Load in Dimension Tables

Good information, thankssehackear.top

Matt Allington's profile image Profile Picture

elias zafrani on 19 Apr 2024 01:12:14

RE: Better Handle Column Types on Load in Dimension Tables

ThanksHackear Instagram Hackear WhatsApp Hackear Facebook

Matt Allington's profile image Profile Picture

Matt Allington on 31 Oct 2022 21:17:54

RE: Better Handle Column Types on Load in Dimension Tables

I believe this has been delivered

Matt Allington's profile image Profile Picture

Steven Doherty on 05 Jul 2020 23:44:44

RE: Better Handle Column Types on Load in Dimension Tables

it's not just the calendar Table. Numeric Index columns also pose the same problem.

Matt Allington's profile image Profile Picture

Nathan Peterson on 05 Jul 2020 23:44:43

RE: Better Handle Column Types on Load in Dimension Tables

It's really not all that bad currently. On the Model view, you can select all the columns in a table and set "Summarize By" to "None". This accomplishes the desired behavior without too much pain.

That said, this would be nice, so I voted. Perhaps there could be a way specify whether a table is a dimension table and act accordingly.

Matt Allington's profile image Profile Picture

Power BI Ideas Admin on 05 Jul 2020 23:44:39

RE: Better Handle Column Types on Load in Dimension Tables

Since calendar are a author-once, ruse everywhere table, I’d like to see a scenario that makes it easier to reuse a calendar table where you manually set the default aggregation once and then reuse the calendar.

Something like a library of frequently reused tables?